London: The fallout from manager Thomas Tuchel’s inaugural England World Cup squad selection continues to provoke intense debate across the sport, with former Watford forward Troy Deeney leading the criticism against the national team boss.

Writing in his syndicated column for The Sun, Deeney expressed profound disbelief regarding the high-profile talent left out of the side as the Three Lions prepare for the upcoming tournament in North America.

"For a nation with A-star talent, we seem to be sending a B-team to the World Cup," Deeney wrote. "Thomas Tuchel has got his principles all muddled up and has selected a squad that, if they do not come back with the trophy, should be a sackable offence."

ALSO READ: FIFA World Cup 2026 Schedule IST

Inconsistencies in Selection Criteria

The core of the public frustration stems from a perceived lack of consistency regarding Tuchel's baseline selection benchmarks. Deeney pointed to contradictory choices within the defensive ranks to highlight the confusion.

"Are we picking on reputation or form and minutes? Jarell Quansah being in there suggests the latter, but then John Stones getting the call-up makes it look like we’re just back to the big names again. Which one is it?" Deeney noted.

Omissions of Foden, Palmer, and Maguire

The most contentious roster decisions involve the complete absence of Manchester United midfielder Phil Foden, the 2023–24 Premier League Player of the Season, alongside Chelsea playmaker Cole Palmer. Adding to the defensive selection debate, veteran centre-back Harry Maguire was also completely omitted from the squad despite his long-standing role as a fixture in England's major tournament defences.

Tuchel has publicly defended his tactical decisions, asserting that he prioritised assembling a collective unit anchored by "hunger and excitement" rather than relying strictly on established historical reputations.

ALSO READ: FIFA World Cup 2026 Broadcast Rights in India

Nevertheless, Deeney remains highly sceptical that England can replicate or improve upon its previous tournament deep runs under former manager Gareth Southgate without its most creative assets and senior leaders.

"The calls to leave Trent Alexander-Arnold, Cole Palmer, and Phil Foden behind could look incredibly stupid in a couple of months," Deeney warned. "Everyone likes the idea of not picking based on names or egos, but that is an awful lot of quality to be left back home and, with this squad, I cannot see Tuchel taking England any further than Gareth Southgate did."

The Midfield Dispute

The inclusion of Brentford midfielder Jordan Henderson emerged as another primary point of contention for critics. Deeney argued that selecting the veteran directly contradicts Tuchel's public messaging regarding physical fitness and consistent competitive playing time.

"We all know that Jordan is there for the vibes, and it is not that he is the problem, but the message was that we’re picking players who are ready and playing," Deeney claimed. "Jordan has been injured and coming off the bench for Brentford."