Ben Stokes was forced to intervene on Day 5 of the fifth Test in Sydney after England fast bowler Brydon Carse angrily confronted third umpire Ahsan Raza following a highly controversial decision that allowed Jake Weatherald to survive early in his innings. Weatherald, playing what was described as a final chance to stake his claim as Australia’s long-term opening option, appeared to be dismissed for 17 when England reviewed an on-field not-out call.

The review initially seemed successful, with a faint spike detected on DRS as the ball passed the bat. However, in a contentious ruling, Raza decided there was insufficient evidence to overturn the original decision. The call infuriated Carse, who approached the umpire in visible frustration, prompting captain Stokes to step in quickly to calm the situation and explain England’s stance.

Former England captain Michael Vaughan strongly criticised the decision during Kayo Sports’ coverage, insisting England had been “hard done by” and questioning how much evidence was required to overturn a call. Graeme Swann echoed those sentiments on TNT Sports, calling the decision “ludicrous” and suggesting the third umpire should be held accountable.

Australian greats Adam Gilchrist and Mark Waugh also agreed Weatherald was fortunate to remain at the crease. Gilchrist praised Stokes for diffusing the situation, noting Carse’s anger, while Waugh questioned England’s hesitation before sending the review upstairs.

The incident sparked debate on social media, with some questioning whether Carse made contact with the umpire. Although Stokes was applauded for his leadership, Carse may face scrutiny from the ICC for his conduct during the confrontation. (With inputs from Agencies)