Can a 16-year-old who commits a serious crime be held accountable in the same way as an adult? Should the age at which a person is considered a juvenile be lowered from 18 to 16? Or would such a move take away a young person's chance of rehabilitation at a stage when their understanding, judgment and ability to make decisions are still developing?

To advertise here,

An observation by the Kerala High Court that it is time for the legislature to consider lowering the age of juvenility from 18 to 16 has brought these questions back into the spotlight. It has also reopened a debate that has remained contentious since the 2012 Delhi gang rape, popularly known as the Nirbhaya case.

At the heart of the debate is a difficult question: Should the seriousness of a crime determine how a young offender is treated, or should age and the possibility of reform remain central to the justice system?

Those supporting a reduction argue that children today grow up with greater access to information and are exposed to social realities much earlier than previous generations. They also point to cases involving older adolescents accused of particularly violent crimes and argue that the existing system may not always ensure adequate accountability.

But access to information does not necessarily translate into emotional maturity or sound judgment. Understanding that an act is wrong, controlling an impulse and appreciating its long-term consequences are different abilities. And these do not necessarily develop at the same pace in every adolescent.

Under the Juvenile Justice (Care and Protection of Children) Act, 2015, anyone below 18 is considered a child. However, the law already allows children between 16 and 18 accused of heinous offences to undergo a preliminary assessment by the Juvenile Justice Board to determine whether they should be tried as adults.

The Kerala High Court's observation has therefore brought the adequacy of this existing provision, and the age threshold itself, into question.

Speaking to Mathrubhumi English, psychiatrist Dr U Vivek of Renai Medicity in Kochi, said the issue cannot be viewed solely through the lens of punishment. The justice system, he said, must balance the interests of victims with accountability and the possibility of reform.

“Three things have to be balanced. There is justice for the victim and the victim’s family, there is accountability for one’s actions, and there is rehabilitation and the possibility of bringing these children back into society. We need an adjustment between all three,” he said.

Dr Vivek said one concern was that some adolescents might believe they could escape serious consequences because they were below 18.

“Sometimes, there is a feeling among children that whatever they do, nothing serious will happen to them. They believe that until they turn 18, the worst that can happen is that they will be sent to a children’s home for a limited period. This perception needs to change,” he said.

He added that adults could also exploit this perception by involving minors in criminal activities, assuming that the children would face relatively limited consequences if caught.

“Age alone cannot be the criterion. A 16-year-old may have the maturity of an 18-year-old, while an 18-year-old may not even have the maturity of a 12-year-old,” he opined.

Dr Vivek said the ability to understand an offence and its consequences should be assessed individually, taking into account psychological development and the circumstances surrounding the crime.

The science behind adolescent behaviour

One of the strongest arguments against a blanket reduction in the age of juvenility comes from neuroscience. The adolescent brain is still developing, particularly the prefrontal cortex, which plays an important role in planning, decision-making, judgment and impulse control. This development continues through adolescence and into early adulthood.

The United Nations Children's Fund (UNICEF) has highlighted how social relationships and the desire for peer acceptance can influence adolescent decision-making. During this stage, the need to fit in, gain approval or avoid rejection can sometimes outweigh a young person's ability to assess risks.

This can make adolescents particularly vulnerable to external influences, especially in emotionally charged situations or when they are with friends.

The World Health Organisation (WHO) has similarly noted that brain systems associated with reward and emotional responses develop earlier than those responsible for executive functions such as impulse control and long-term planning.

The distinction matters when assessing criminal responsibility. A teenager may know that an act is wrong but still struggle to resist peer pressure or control an impulsive response.

Dr Vivek said several factors, including substance use and underlying psychological conditions, could influence behaviour.

“Alcohol, cannabis and other substances can increase impulsivity. There may also be underlying conditions such as untreated ADHD. Several factors influence a person’s behaviour. If we consider age alone, we may not arrive at the right conclusion,” he said.

A childhood lost behind prison walls?

For human rights lawyer and activist Sandhya Raju, lowering the age of juvenility could put the rehabilitative purpose of the juvenile justice system at risk.

She said the age of 18 was not chosen arbitrarily but after considering scientific and developmental factors. Public anger over particularly disturbing crimes, she argued, should not become the basis for changing a law designed to give children an opportunity to reform.

“The age limit in the Juvenile Justice Act was not fixed arbitrarily. It was arrived at after considering scientific assessments and several other factors. The juvenile justice system provides an opportunity for children to return to society and rebuild their lives,” she said.

Raju warned that treating children between 16 and 18 as adults could expose them to prison environments and the influence of hardened criminals, making rehabilitation more difficult.

“If we start treating 16 to 18-year-olds as adults and send them to prison, they could be exposed to the influence of other prisoners. What happens to their future rehabilitation? The purpose of the correctional system is not merely to punish them. It is to correct their behaviour and bring them back into society,” she said.

She also cautioned against viewing juvenile crime as the result of an individual's actions alone. Peer pressure, economic vulnerability and the influence of older people can all play a role in drawing children into criminal activities.

“Many children do not commit these offences independently. They may be in the company of adults who are 19, 20 or 21 years old. Others may be part of groups where they feel pressured to participate. Sometimes, fear of being excluded from the group also influences their actions,” she said.

The Nirbhaya case, Raju said, illustrates how public outrage can shape discussions on juvenile justice. Following the 2012 crime, the law was amended in 2015 to allow children aged 16 to 18 accused of heinous offences to be assessed for a possible trial as adults.

But Sandhya Raju said the focus should remain on what happens to children after they enter the correctional system.

“The three years that a child may spend in a correctional institution should not simply be a period of confinement. There should be proper rehabilitation, education and reintegration. A child can still be brought back into society. We should explore that possibility rather than assume that the child’s future is over,” she opined.

Sandhya Raju also raised concerns about inequalities in access to justice. Children from economically disadvantaged families may not have the parental support, legal assistance or resources needed to navigate the juvenile justice system.

“Before discussing a reduction in age, we must examine whether the facilities required for rehabilitation and reintegration are actually available. We cannot make a decision based on emotions surrounding one particular case,” she said.

Are today's children more mature?

While the arguments against lowering the age largely centre on adolescent brain development, Dr Arun B Nair of the Department of Psychiatry at the Medical College in Thiruvananthapuram, said changes in children's access to information should also be considered.

Children today encounter information, social issues and experiences much earlier than previous generations, largely because of the internet and digital platforms. This, he said, can accelerate the development of certain aspects of their knowledge and understanding.

“From a scientific point of view, brain development continues until around the age of 25. The prefrontal cortex, which is the centre associated with judgment and decision-making, takes time to mature. The brain continues developing during this period… Today’s children have access to several sources of information, including the internet. Earlier, children had to learn many things through school, education and life experiences. Today, information is readily available. In that sense, children may acquire knowledge and understanding much earlier,” Dr Arun said.

He argued that these changes should form part of the discussion on whether the existing age threshold needs reconsideration.

“From that perspective, there is an argument that we do not necessarily have to wait until 18 to recognise that some children have acquired considerable knowledge and understanding,” he said.

However, he cautioned that changing the age of criminal responsibility could have implications beyond the juvenile justice system.

“If we give a 16-year-old full legal responsibility, we also have to consider the minimum age for giving consent and undertaking other legal transactions. It could affect the age at which a person can open a bank account, buy and sell property, hold property and give consent to sexual relationships,” he added.

He said the wider social and family implications of such a move would need to be examined, particularly in the Indian context.

The Nirbhaya precedent and the limits of the law

The Nirbhaya case remains a turning point in India's debate over juvenile justice. One of the accused was 17 at the time of the crime and was dealt with under the juvenile justice framework then in force. The maximum period of institutionalisation under the law was three years.

The public outrage that followed intensified demands for a change in the law. The Juvenile Justice Act, 2015, retained 18 as the general age of juvenility but introduced a provision allowing the Juvenile Justice Board to conduct a preliminary assessment of children aged 16 to 18 accused of heinous offences.

The assessment considers the child's mental and physical capacity to commit the alleged offence, the ability to understand its consequences and the circumstances in which it was committed.

The provision was intended to address concerns over serious crimes involving older adolescents without automatically treating every child in that age group as an adult.

Sandhya Raju said the existence of this provision makes it necessary to examine whether further changes are justified.

Dr Vivek, meanwhile, maintained that individual assessments are preferable to a uniform approach.

“Sometimes, a 16-year-old may have the capacity to understand the consequences of an act, while another person of the same age may not. We need to examine the individual’s development, psychological condition, intellectual capacity and the circumstances surrounding the offence,” he said.

A legislative decision, not just a judicial observation

The High Court's observation has also brought the legal process into focus. The Juvenile Justice Act is a central piece of legislation. Any substantial change to its general age threshold would require legislative action at the appropriate level. A judicial observation or an announcement by a state government cannot, by itself, change the existing legal framework.

India's obligations under the United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child also form an important part of the discussion. The convention defines a child as every human being below 18, placing the proposed reduction in a wider international child rights context. 

“We need a proper study. We cannot make such a decision merely because a court has made an observation or because people are emotionally affected by a particular incident. There must be logic and a scientific basis,” Sandhya Raju said.

The question is not whether serious crimes committed by adolescents should be taken lightly. It is whether lowering the age of juvenility would deliver greater accountability without closing the door to rehabilitation.

As the discussion moves beyond the courtroom, lawmakers will have to weigh the demands for justice against what science, child development and experience tell us about growing up. A 16-year-old may be capable of understanding the seriousness of an offence, but that does not necessarily mean they possess the judgment and emotional maturity of an adult.

Child rights commission stresses rehabilitation over punishment

Cicily Joseph, member and acting chairperson of the Kerala State Commission for Protection of Child Rights, opposed lowering the age of juvenility, stressing that a child's psychological development, family circumstances and social environment must be considered before they are treated as adults.

Referring to the UN Convention on the Rights of the Child, which recognises everyone below 18 as a child, she said greater exposure to information and changes in children's behaviour should not be mistaken for adult maturity.

"The prefrontal cortex, which is associated with decision-making and reasoning, is still developing. While children today are also committing serious offences, we must understand why they are doing so," she said.

Joseph pointed to irresponsible parenting, neglect, lack of supervision and family breakdown as possible factors contributing to juvenile offending. She said the circumstances that lead a child towards crime must be examined instead of placing the entire responsibility on the child.

"If we consider 16-year-olds mature enough to be treated as adults in criminal cases, should we also allow them to marry or grant them voting rights at that age? We say children should be allowed to enjoy their childhood," she said.

She also highlighted the role of the existing juvenile justice system, which focuses on correction and rehabilitation through observation homes, special homes and other arrangements rather than sending children directly to prison.

"Simply punishing children may not reduce crime. We need corrective measures and a positive approach, with parenting support forming an important part of the process," she said.

Joseph said parents, schools, teachers and local bodies all have a role to play in helping children who come into conflict with the law return to society.

"Instead of finding ways to guide and reform them, people often demand that such children be sent to jail. I cannot think that way when it comes to children's rights," she said.