Marnus Labuschagne produced an unexpected breakthrough for Australia, claiming the wicket of Jamie Smith after what was widely described as a rash and ill-judged shot in the ongoing Test match.

Introduced into the attack, Labuschagne needed just one over to make an impact. There was little threat in the delivery itself, but Smith, batting on 46, attempted an ambitious stroke and picked out Scott Boland on the off side. The dismissal sparked strong reactions in the commentary box.

Former Australia coach Justin Langer did not hold back, branding it “one of the dumbest shots you’ll ever see in Test cricket” while speaking on Seven. Langer pointed out that Smith had already enjoyed good fortune earlier in his innings and questioned the decision-making behind the stroke in a five-day format.

Smith had, in fact, survived two significant let-offs earlier, both involving Cameron Green. The first came when Smith chipped a straightforward catch to cover, only for it to be ruled a no-ball after Green was found to have overstepped. Soon after, Smith edged between first slip and the wicketkeeper, with Beau Webster unable to react in time.

Stuart Broad described it as “a horrible dismissal” and suggested Smith looked unsettled at the crease, while James Brayshaw noted Webster’s uncharacteristic lapse in the field. Broad added that Smith appeared “a bit jumpy” and questioned his shot selection given Joe Root was well set at the other end.

Langer later issued an on-air apology for doubting the decision to bowl Labuschagne, praising the Australian all-rounder’s effort while reiterating his criticism of the batting. He labelled Smith’s dismissal “almost unforgivable” and raised concerns about England’s leadership and messaging, particularly for a player potentially fighting for his place.

At the time of writing, England were batting at 384/9, looking to get past the 400 mark. (With inputs from Agencies)