The missed dismissal proved costly as Phillips (94*) and Henry Nicholls formed an unbroken 173-run partnership, dragging New Zealand from a precarious 70-5 to a resilient 243-5 by stumps.

Wellington: A fierce officiating controversy erupted on Day 1 of the first Test between India and New Zealand at the Basin Reserve in Wellington on Thursday, 19 November 2026. With the hosts reeling at 70 for five in the 31st over, Jasprit Bumrah beat Glenn Phillips’ defensive prod with a sharp nip-backer that struck the batter’s back pad. Following a loud leg-before-wicket appeal, on-field umpire Richard Illingworth shook his head. Bumrah expressed reservations over the delivery's bounce, yet India captain Shubman Gill insisted there was no bat involved and immediately signalled for the Decision Review System.
ALSO READ: IND vs NZ Test: Five down before 100, how India's bowlers exposed New Zealand's batting weakness
Conflicting Replays Spark Touchline Frustration
The subsequent television review triggered widespread debate across the ground. While UltraEdge technology registered a distinct spike as the ball passed the inside edge, front-on camera angles appeared to show a visible gap between bat and ball. After scrutinising multiple slow-motion replays, third umpire Paul Reiffel ruled that the ball had taken a faint deflection off the willow before hitting the pad, thereby upholding Illingworth’s original not-out verdict and costing India a valuable review. A visibly enraged Gill approached Illingworth for an animated discussion, gesturing to highlight the apparent separation between bat and pad before reluctantly returning to his fielding position.
ALSO READ: Sunil Gavaskar opens up on iconic 1971 West Indies calypso tribute
Reprieve Proves Costly as Kiwis Fight Back
Although ball-tracking projections suggested the delivery might have cleared the bails anyway, the reprieve proved a major turning point in the contest. Capitalising on his lifeline, Phillips anchored a resilient, unbroken 173-run stand alongside century-maker Henry Nicholls, reaching stumps unbeaten on 94 off 182 deliveries as New Zealand recovered to 243 for five.
Published: 19 Nov 2026, 06:14 pm IST
ABOUT THE AUTHOR
Get Latest Mathrubhumi Updates in English
Disclaimer: Kindly avoid objectionable, derogatory, unlawful and lewd comments, while responding to reports. Such comments are punishable under cyber laws. Please keep away from personal attacks. The opinions expressed here are the personal opinions of readers and not that of Mathrubhumi.

