Nimisha Priya case: Social media backlash complicates pardon efforts in Yemen

Kozhikode: A wave of critical comments under the Facebook posts of Abdul Fattah Mehdi, brother of murdered Yemeni national Talal, has triggered emotional reactions among Yemenis and is reportedly complicating efforts to secure the release of Nimisha Priya, the Indian nurse facing death penalty in Yemen.

Several users from Kerala have posted remarks such as “Don’t forgive Nimisha Priya,” “Your brother deserves justice,” and “Are you making money by selling your brother’s blood?” on Mehdi’s Facebook page. Many of these comments have been translated into Arabic to ensure they are understood by Talal’s family. Some posts have also targeted prominent figures like Kanthapuram A P Aboobacker Musliyar and Yemeni Sufi scholar Habib Umar bin Hafiz, both of whom have intervened in the case in an attempt to avoid capital punishment.

According to Action Council office-bearers, malicious translations of discussions from Kerala are being shared with Talal’s family, potentially harming delicate negotiations for a pardon. “There is concern that these actions could obstruct ongoing efforts,” the council said.

Nimisha Priya’s Mother Appeals for Compassion

Speaking from Yemen, Nimisha’s mother Premakumari, made an emotional appeal to Talal’s family. “Talal is like a son to me. What happened to him hurts me just as much as if it happened to my own child,” she told Mathrubhumi News. “I apologise from the depths of my heart. I am even ready to sacrifice my life. I beg everyone not to let any negative information reach that family.”

She also expressed anguish over her inability to communicate directly with her daughter. “I can’t speak to Nimisha by phone or video. She only sends me messages now and then, asking how we are. I plead with everyone—please don’t let anything worsen this situation.”

Talal’s Brother Stands Firm: “Retribution, Not Reconciliation”

In a strongly worded Facebook post written in Arabic, Abdul Fattah Mehdi confirmed that the family remains steadfast in demanding retribution, not reconciliation. “The postponement of the execution is unfortunate and unexpected,” he wrote. “The Indian media is trying to twist the facts and portray the killer as a victim. Murder cannot be justified.”

He stated that despite years of secret mediations and intense pressure, the family’s stance has never changed. “Delay won’t bend us, pressure won’t move us, and blood cannot be bought. Retribution will come, no matter how long the road. It is only a matter of time, with God’s help,” he said.

Talks Ongoing, Council Hopeful

Despite the firm response from Talal’s family, the Action Council remains optimistic. They believe the influence of Sufi scholar Habib Umar bin Hafiz could prove crucial. Acting on his instructions, the Chief Justice of the Hodeidah State Court has been holding dialogue with Talal’s family.

Speaking to the media after meeting A.P. Aboobacker Musliyar at the Markaz in Karanthur, Action Council members said discussions were still progressing.

“Talks took place on Wednesday as well. Things are moving in a positive direction,” said Neev Kumar, core committee member, and treasurer Kunjahammed Chund. “If forgiveness is granted, the compensation money is ready. The global Malayali community has shown its support.”