EPFO plans all-out legal battle against pensioner-friendly rulings, moves to defend pro-rata formula

Authored By: Shine Mohan
Representational image.| AI generated.
Representational image.| AI generated.

The Employees' Provident Fund Organisation (EPFO) has prepared a comprehensive strategy to defend its decisions on higher pension for Employees' Provident Fund (EPF) members in various High Courts and the Supreme Court.

The organisation's strategy is based on its position that decisions, including the pro-rata method used to calculate higher pensions, were taken in consultation with the Centre following the Supreme Court's 2022 verdict on the issue.

The proposed legal strategy will be discussed at the EPFO's Central Board of Trustees meeting scheduled for Thursday (November 19). The board will consider how to handle the pending cases in various High Courts and the Supreme Court.

Although the EPFO has settled 99 per cent of applications seeking higher pensions, it considers the continuing legal challenges a major concern.

There are currently 2,871 cases related to higher pensions pending in various High Courts. These cases involve several contentious decisions taken by the EPFO.

They include the rejection of higher pension applications from employees of establishments that manage their own provident funds, citing restrictions in their trust rules. Challenges have also been raised against the pro-rata formula, which has significantly reduced pension amounts for some applicants.

Other disputes concern the rejection of applications from employees who retired before September 1, 2014, without exercising the higher pension option. Cases have also been filed against the discontinuation of higher pensions granted following the Supreme Court's 2016 judgement in the R.C. Gupta case.

The EPFO held a special workshop on February 2 to formulate strategies for dealing with the pending cases. The organisation's counsel in the Supreme Court and senior officials from various zones participated in the meeting and provided guidance to field officers.

The 2016 R.C. Gupta judgement had allowed several employees to receive higher pensions by holding that there could be no deadline for exercising the pension option.

However, payments to many such pensioners were discontinued following the Supreme Court's 2022 verdict. The EPFO has directed its officials to strongly defend its position against court decisions favouring pensioners, including those delivered by the Kerala High Court.

The pro-rata method used by the EPFO to calculate higher pensions has also faced challenges in different courts.

A single-judge bench of the Punjab and Haryana High Court had struck down the formula. However, a division bench stayed the order following an appeal filed by the EPFO.

The EPFO has also appealed before a division bench of the Calcutta High Court against a ruling that struck down the pro-rata calculation method.