What is membranous nephropathy? The kidney disease at the centre of Keralam's fairness cream cases

Compiled By: Deepak Rajeev
Singer Saleem Kodathoor (left), Representative image (right) | Photo: Facebook, Magnific
Singer Saleem Kodathoor (left), Representative image (right) | Photo: Facebook, Magnific

A 17-year-old girl in Keralam and singer Saleem Kodathoor have brought attention to a serious kidney condition called membranous nephropathy after speaking about health problems they experienced following the use of fairness creams.

In the teenager's case, doctors at Aster MIMS Mother Hospital in Malappuram said tests detected dangerously high levels of mercury in her body. They also reported that the cream she used contained 12,500 parts per million (ppm) of mercury, against the permissible level of less than one ppm.

Saleem, meanwhile, has said he developed the same kidney disease after using a fairness cream about 10 years ago. In a Facebook video, he recalled months of hospital visits and intensive treatment, saying the illness affected his health, career and finances.

But what is membranous nephropathy? How does it affect the kidneys, what causes it, and can it lead to kidney failure?

What is membranous nephropathy?

Membranous nephropathy is a kidney disease that damages the tiny filtering units inside the kidneys, called glomeruli. These filters remove waste and excess fluid from the blood while retaining essential substances such as proteins.

In this condition, the body's immune system mistakenly attacks these filtering units, causing them to become damaged. As a result, proteins that should remain in the blood begin leaking into the urine.

One important protein affected is albumin, which helps maintain the right balance of fluid in the body. When too much albumin is lost through urine, fluid can accumulate in different parts of the body, causing swelling.

The disease may develop slowly, and some people may not notice symptoms for a long time.

Symptoms to watch out for

One of the common signs of membranous nephropathy is unusually foamy or frothy urine. This happens because excess protein is being passed through the urine.

Swelling around the eyes, eyelids, legs and feet is another important warning sign. Some people may also experience weight gain due to fluid retention, persistent tiredness and changes in the amount of urine they pass.

In more serious cases, fluid accumulation can cause breathing difficulties. High blood pressure and increased cholesterol levels may also occur.

These symptoms do not necessarily mean a person has membranous nephropathy. However, unexplained swelling or persistent frothy urine should be evaluated by a doctor.

What causes membranous nephropathy?

The disease is broadly classified into two types: primary and secondary membranous nephropathy.

Primary membranous nephropathy occurs when the immune system mistakenly attacks healthy parts of the kidney. In many cases, the immune system produces antibodies against a protein called PLA2R, which is found in kidney cells.

Secondary membranous nephropathy develops when another health condition, medication or exposure to a harmful substance damages the kidneys.

Conditions such as lupus and rheumatoid arthritis, infections including hepatitis B and hepatitis C, and certain medicines can be associated with the disease. Exposure to toxic substances such as mercury is another recognised possible cause.

In some cases, doctors may not be able to identify the exact cause.

How can mercury exposure affect the kidneys

Mercury is a toxic heavy metal that can damage several organs, including the kidneys. Since the kidneys filter waste and harmful substances from the blood, exposure to toxic levels of mercury can interfere with their normal functioning.

The Cleveland Clinic identifies mercury exposure as one of the factors associated with secondary membranous nephropathy.

This has become particularly relevant in Keralam following the case of the 17-year-old girl from Malappuram. Doctors treating her said tests detected dangerously high mercury levels in her body. 

The girl had reportedly bought the product online after watching Instagram influencers promote it as a solution for pimples, dark spots and pigmentation. She continued using the cream and ordered several more bottles over the following year.

Doctors said the mercury exposure had damaged her kidney filters, resulting in membranous nephropathy.

The case has raised concerns about skin-lightening products sold online, especially those promising quick changes in skin tone without clear information about their ingredients.

Singer Saleem Kodathoor's experience

Saleem Kodathoor has also spoken about developing membranous nephropathy after using a fairness cream around 10 years ago.

He said he started using the product after noticing that another singer had become visibly fairer. His skin tone changed within a week, but health problems began about a month and a half later.

According to Saleem, he initially developed a urinary tract infection, followed by swelling around his eyes and legs. He also noticed excessive frothing in his urine.

Medical tests revealed that his body was losing large amounts of protein. A kidney biopsy subsequently confirmed membranous nephropathy, he said.

The singer recalled undergoing treatment for about eight months, with hospital admissions every month. When the initial medication failed to improve his condition, doctors started steroid treatment.

Although he said he eventually recovered from the illness, its effects continued to trouble him. He lost nearly a year of his career, cancelled several programmes and suffered significant financial losses. He also reported persistent fatigue and sleep problems.

Saleem said one of four friends who had used the same cream also developed the illness. He later came across other people who reported similar health problems after using fairness creams sold under different names.

Tests used to diagnose the disease

Doctors use blood and urine tests to check for signs of kidney damage. A urine test can detect excessive protein loss, while blood tests help measure albumin levels and assess kidney function.

They may also check the glomerular filtration rate (GFR), which indicates how effectively the kidneys are filtering waste from the blood.

A kidney biopsy is often used to confirm membranous nephropathy. In this procedure, doctors take a small sample of kidney tissue and examine it for characteristic signs of the disease.

Treatment and management

Treatment depends on the cause of the disease, the amount of kidney damage and the severity of the symptoms.

Some patients improve without intensive treatment, while others need medication to control the disease and prevent further damage.

Doctors may prescribe medicines to control blood pressure and reduce protein loss through urine. Diuretics can help remove excess fluid and reduce swelling. Some patients may also need medicines to control cholesterol levels.

In more serious cases, corticosteroids or other medicines that suppress the immune system may be prescribed to prevent further damage to the kidney filters.

When the condition is linked to an underlying disease or exposure to a harmful substance, addressing that cause is also important.

Can it lead to kidney failure?

Membranous nephropathy does not always lead to kidney failure. The outcome varies from person to person, depending on the severity of the condition and how well it responds to treatment.

Some patients achieve remission, meaning the disease becomes inactive and protein loss reduces significantly. Others may experience continued kidney damage over several years.

According to the Cleveland Clinic, fewer than 15% of people with membranous nephropathy develop kidney failure. In severe cases, patients may eventually require dialysis or a kidney transplant.

The disease can also return after treatment, making regular kidney-function tests and follow-up with a nephrologist important.

What precautions should we take?

The recent cases in Keralam have highlighted the importance of taking precautions when buying and using skin-lightening products, particularly those promoted through social media.

- Check product ingredients: Avoid skin-lightening creams that do not disclose their ingredients, manufacturer details or regulatory approvals. Be particularly cautious of products promising instant fairness or dramatic changes in skin tone.

- Avoid unverified online products: Do not buy or use creams from unverified sellers or social media advertisements. Products containing harmful substances such as mercury can cause serious health complications, including kidney damage.

- Consult a dermatologist: If you experience acne, pigmentation or other skin problems, seek advice from a qualified dermatologist instead of relying on unverified fairness creams or self-medication.

- Watch for kidney-related symptoms: Unexplained swelling around the eyes, face or legs, persistent foamy urine and changes in urination should not be ignored. Consult a doctor if you notice these symptoms.

- Keep track of kidney health: If you have kidney disease, understand your condition and monitor important indicators such as serum creatinine and estimated glomerular filtration rate (eGFR). Regular medical check-ups can help detect changes in kidney function.

- Manage diabetes and blood pressure: Both conditions are major risk factors for kidney damage. Follow your healthcare team's advice to keep blood sugar and blood pressure under control.

- Follow a healthy lifestyle: Avoid smoking, limit salt intake and maintain a balanced diet. Drink adequate fluids unless your doctor has advised you to restrict fluid consumption.

- Be careful with medicines: Inform your doctor and pharmacist if you have kidney disease. Certain medicines, including non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drugs (NSAIDs) such as ibuprofen, can affect kidney function, particularly when used frequently

Membranous nephropathy can have several underlying causes, and not every case is linked to mercury exposure or fairness creams. However, the recent reports underline the potential dangers of using unregulated skin-lightening products and the importance of protecting kidney health.