• News
  • Movies
  • Money
  • Health
  • Features
More
Hero Hero
  • Social Issues
  • Women & Children
  • Specials
  • Travel
  • Health
  • Agriculture
  • Web Exclusive
  • Sports

COVID-19 measures should also acknowledge Mumbai’s poor

The most vulnerable, like those without shelter; domestics in over-crowded hovels; rag-pickers and others of similar tribe who drives the vast engine of the maximum city too should be brought under the pandemic protocol, if contagion has to contained in Mumbai

# Kalpana Sharma (kalpu.sharma@gmail.com)
Apr 7, 2020, 08:21 PM IST
T- T T+
1
X
×
Streets are the home and hearth of the urban poor like Uma in Mumbai (photo courtesy: Scroll.in)

She lies on the pavement, every part of her body covered with a thin sheet. I pass by her every day. This is Uma, a child of the street, who will turn 18 next month. At the age of 16 she gave birth to a little girl, who will turn two next month.

As our world staggers with the reality of a deadly virus that is crossing borders and regions, spare a thought for those like Uma and her child. She has no walls that can provide her social isolation. She has no water with which to wash her hands. And she has no confidence to approach a health provider for fear she will be turned away. And this, in India’s richest city, Mumbai.

The crisis the world, and India, face with the steady spread of COVID-19, has exposed much about our societies. In India, above all it has exposed the callousness of the entitled and the weakness of our public health system.

The fact that the virus came to India because those with the money to travel abroad brought it in has still not sunk in. Every day you read stories of people who have travelled refusing to accept that they should voluntarily stay at home and not infect others, that they should get tested when required, and that they should accept isolation if tested positive.

Instead, what we witness is many who are simply not following this protocol. As a result, even though so far we are being told that there is no community spread of the virus, do we really know? Already in Mumbai, a domestic help tested positive because she works in a house where the owner, who had just returned from the US, tested positive. Multiply such instances and you get the picture.

2
Cramped living conditions are no match for the innate doughtiness of Mumbai’s smiling menials, the unacknowledged artisans of honest labour (photo courtesy: Brooklyn meets Bombay)

And then, the women who work as domestics live in over-crowded urban settlements, where dozens occupy tiny spaces, where water is scarce and sanitation inadequate. The idea of “social isolation” in such a place is unimaginable.

How long before the infection spreads, if it has not already done so?

I ask because even as we concentrate on limiting the spread of infection, and increasing our capacity to test for COVID-19, we also need to address the unchanging reality like the living conditions of the urban poor that make the spread of infection virtually inevitable.

The most vulnerable are those without any shelter, like Uma. She is part of a family of waste pickers. Every day, they sort dry waste. They touch paper, cardboard, plastic and other forms of waste that would have been touched by many hands, including those with the infection. I haven’t heard of any plan to keep these citizens of our cities safe from infection.

Instead, middle class housing societies are talking of ways to shut the poor out, in the belief that they are the ones who carry the infection. Typically, they refuse to accept that it is their class that has contributed to the spread of the infection.

Not just accidentally because they happened to be in the countries that had already been stung by COVID-19. But by refusing to take the necessary precautions, such as social isolation and testing to ensure that no one else gets it.

If there is anything I wish at this time of death and disease it is that those with wealth realise that if we have a system that works for the poor, it will work for everyone. On the other hand, no privatised health system can prevent the spread of a deadly virus because it will automatically exclude those who are the most vulnerable, people like Uma. 

(English original of the article in the fortnightly column titled ‘Akakkannu’ published in Mathrubhumi daily on March 29, 2020)

PRINT
EMAIL
COMMENT
 

Related Articles

India may get vax nod for emergency use by December end
News |
News |
With low testing, Kerala reports 3,047 new Covid-19 cases; test positivity rate at 9.27 percent
News |
Saudi extends suspension of flights by another week over Covid strain
News |
Over 20,000 new Covid infections reported in single-day
 
 
  • Tags :
    • Coronavirus
More from this section
Oslo Metropolitan University students
Students map social change wrought by Norwegian aid and expertise in Neendakara fishing community
Nirbhaya
Why rapes will not stop in India despite the forthcoming four hangings
NRC
CAA, NPR, NRC and a confused NRI
Bharathapuzha
How Bharathappuzha is being revived - a case study
police
Experts say 'bad precedent', as people celebrate Bollywood style Hyd encounter
News in Videos
News+ Kerala India NRI World Columns Features Offbeat Good News Crime
Leisure Movies & Music Sports Travel Books
Learn Money Education Agriculture
Lifestyle Health Tech Food Astrology
Multimedia Gallery Videos Mojo News News In Pics
Our Network Malayalam Print Mathrubhumi News TV Kappa TV Club FM Seed Silver Bullet FindHome Media School MBIFL Redmic
E-Paper
Subscription
Buy Books
Magazines
Classifieds
Archives
 
  • E-Paper
  • Subscription
  • Buy Books
  • Magazines
  • Classifieds
  • Archives
© Copyright Mathrubhumi 2020. All rights reserved.
About Us Contact Us Privacy Policy
Terms of Use Archives
Ad Tariff Download App Classifieds
Buy Books Subscription e-Subscription
 
           
© Copyright Mathrubhumi 2020. All rights reserved.